DRAFT QA · incomplete seven-brand scoring · do not publish

Clean Health Lab · static evidence review · September 13, 2026

Twenty-brand PDP visual benchmark

A plain-English visual benchmark of 20 product pages. Thirteen accepted assessments are preserved exactly; seven pages were completed with fresh evidence and two independent judges.

Original scoring rubric (verbatim) · Report data · Method/status

All 20 brands

The table shows every brand and both judge scores. The seven fresh reviews have detailed cards with their cited evidence below.

BrandCraft judge overallCraftJourney judge overallJourneyScope

Consensus and disagreements

Pending root review of both judge lanes.
Thirteen accepted assessments — unchanged

These score records pass through unchanged from the accepted benchmark. Open their published evidence report.

Evidence frame