DRAFT QA · provisional judge files · zero recovered assessments accepted

Clean Health Lab · static evidence review · September 13, 2026

Recovered-nine PDP visual benchmark

Two independent visual reviews of nine recovered product pages. Partial captures have scoped scores; the original eleven reviews are preserved below.

Original scoring rubric (verbatim) · Report data · Method/status

Recovered nine

The table gives the review state at a glance. Open each card for per-device coverage, both independent score records, cited rationales, findings, and the complete ordered frame set.

BrandCraft judge overallJourney judge overallScope

Consensus and disagreements

Pending root review of both judge lanes.
Original eleven — unchanged reference cohort

These entries were not rescored in the recovery pass. Open the original benchmark and evidence.

Evidence frame