RAW — five headlines × two plate families (couple scene / winner-style still life), Meta safe-zone layout, paired 4:5 / 9:16, A/B = CTA copy

Same architecture as the winner: provocation hook (one red word) → pain + pheromone mechanism (italic) → 4.8 · 12,400+ verified reviews → three real RAW sprays + roll-on → 78% Off — Today Only → $75 bundle · She makes the first move · 60-day guarantee → white pill CTA. Round 2: every 9:16 keeps headline, proof, product, offer and CTA inside Meta’s safe box (y 269–1248); the two small sub lines sit under the CTA in the bottom band and are the only secondary element there. Every 4:5 keeps all copy inside y 169–1181 (survives a 1:1 crop). Measured per master in qa/safe-zones.json. Plates: OpenAI gpt-image-2.5-sunburst with the five RAW product references attached (per-plate receipt in source-original/logs). Type: Remotion, deterministic, the winner's V85 serif system. Curse words asterisked. Status per master is the canonical rendered-typography craft audit. pair-pass stamp present (.pair-pass.json). No blind judge has run; nothing here is launch-approved until the operator Keeps it.

Contact sheets (A arm)

Reference — the live winner (GODA5H-PT, creative 2110779233123572)

Not part of the batch. Shown so the five can be judged against what is actually selling.

winner 4:5
winner 9:16

V1P — I Thought Pheromones Were Bullsh*t.

Then she asked what I was wearing. Then she asked me home. · couple scene · one spray + roll-on sharp in front · A: CLAIM 78% OFF → · B: SHOP THE $75 BUNDLE →

plate 4x5
v1p-a-4x5 · HARD_GATES_PASS · feed ✓ · 1:1 crop ✗
v1p-b-4x5 · HARD_GATES_PASS · feed ✓ · 1:1 crop ✗
plate 9x16
v1p-a-9x16 · HARD_GATES_PASS · Stories ✗ proof:y1519-1561,offer:y1585-1666,cta:y1721-1764
v1p-b-9x16 · HARD_GATES_PASS · Stories ✗ proof:y1519-1561,offer:y1585-1666,cta:y1717-1768

V1S — I Thought Pheromones Were Bullsh*t.

Then she asked what I was wearing. Then she asked me home. · winner-style still life · three sprays + roll-on · A: CLAIM 78% OFF → · B: SHOP THE $75 BUNDLE →

plate 4x5
v1s-a-4x5 · HARD_GATES_PASS · feed ✓ · 1:1 crop ✓
v1s-b-4x5 · HARD_GATES_PASS · feed ✓ · 1:1 crop ✓
plate 9x16
v1s-a-9x16 · HARD_GATES_PASS · Stories-safe ✓ / Reels band ✗
v1s-b-9x16 · HARD_GATES_PASS · Stories-safe ✓ / Reels band ✗

V2P — Your Cologne Doesn’t Do Sh*t.

It smells nice. That’s all it does. Pheromones make her move. · couple scene · one spray + roll-on sharp in front · A: CLAIM 78% OFF → · B: SHOP THE $75 BUNDLE →

plate 4x5
v2p-a-4x5 · HARD_GATES_PASS · feed ✓ · 1:1 crop ✓
v2p-b-4x5 · HARD_GATES_PASS · feed ✓ · 1:1 crop ✓
plate 9x16
v2p-a-9x16 · HARD_GATES_PASS · Stories-safe ✓ / Reels band ✗
v2p-b-9x16 · HARD_GATES_PASS · Stories-safe ✓ / Reels band ✗

V2S — Your Cologne Doesn’t Do Sh*t.

It smells nice. That’s all it does. Pheromones make her move. · winner-style still life · three sprays + roll-on · A: CLAIM 78% OFF → · B: SHOP THE $75 BUNDLE →

plate 4x5
v2s-a-4x5 · HARD_GATES_PASS · feed ✓ · 1:1 crop ✓
v2s-b-4x5 · HARD_GATES_PASS · feed ✓ · 1:1 crop ✓
plate 9x16
v2s-a-9x16 · HARD_GATES_PASS · Stories-safe ✓ / Reels band ✗
v2s-b-9x16 · HARD_GATES_PASS · Stories-safe ✓ / Reels band ✗

V3P — Cologne Never Got Anyone Laid.

Pheromones did. Two sprays and she’s the one leaning in. · couple scene · one spray + roll-on sharp in front · A: CLAIM 78% OFF → · B: SHOP THE $75 BUNDLE →

plate 4x5
v3p-a-4x5 · HARD_GATES_PASS · feed ✓ · 1:1 crop ✓
v3p-b-4x5 · HARD_GATES_PASS · feed ✓ · 1:1 crop ✓
plate 9x16
v3p-a-9x16 · HARD_GATES_PASS · Stories-safe ✓ / Reels band ✗
v3p-b-9x16 · HARD_GATES_PASS · Stories-safe ✓ / Reels band ✗

V3S — Cologne Never Got Anyone Laid.

Pheromones did. Two sprays and she’s the one leaning in. · winner-style still life · three sprays + roll-on · A: CLAIM 78% OFF → · B: SHOP THE $75 BUNDLE →

plate 4x5
v3s-a-4x5 · HARD_GATES_PASS · feed ✓ · 1:1 crop ✓
v3s-b-4x5 · HARD_GATES_PASS · feed ✓ · 1:1 crop ✓
plate 9x16
v3s-a-9x16 · HARD_GATES_PASS · Stories-safe ✓ / Reels band ✗
v3s-b-9x16 · HARD_GATES_PASS · Stories-safe ✓ / Reels band ✗

V4P — Nice Cologne. Still Sleeping Alone.

A good scent gets a compliment. Pheromones get her to stay. · couple scene · one spray + roll-on sharp in front · A: CLAIM 78% OFF → · B: SHOP THE $75 BUNDLE →

plate 4x5
v4p-a-4x5 · HARD_GATES_PASS · feed ✓ · 1:1 crop ✗
v4p-b-4x5 · HARD_GATES_PASS · feed ✓ · 1:1 crop ✗
plate 9x16
v4p-a-9x16 · HARD_GATES_PASS · Stories ✗ proof:y1317-1359,offer:y1383-1464,cta:y1519-1562
v4p-b-9x16 · HARD_GATES_PASS · Stories ✗ proof:y1317-1359,offer:y1383-1464,cta:y1515-1566

V4S — Nice Cologne. Still Sleeping Alone.

A good scent gets a compliment. Pheromones get her to stay. · winner-style still life · three sprays + roll-on · A: CLAIM 78% OFF → · B: SHOP THE $75 BUNDLE →

plate 4x5
v4s-a-4x5 · HARD_GATES_PASS · feed ✓ · 1:1 crop ✓
v4s-b-4x5 · HARD_GATES_PASS · feed ✓ · 1:1 crop ✓
plate 9x16
v4s-a-9x16 · HARD_GATES_PASS · Stories-safe ✓ / Reels band ✗
v4s-b-9x16 · HARD_GATES_PASS · Stories-safe ✓ / Reels band ✗

V5P — F**k Smelling Nice. Start Getting Laid.

Nice is forgettable. Pheromones bring her over. · couple scene · one spray + roll-on sharp in front · A: CLAIM 78% OFF → · B: SHOP THE $75 BUNDLE →

plate 4x5
v5p-a-4x5 · HARD_GATES_PASS · feed ✓ · 1:1 crop ✓
v5p-b-4x5 · HARD_GATES_PASS · feed ✓ · 1:1 crop ✓
plate 9x16
v5p-a-9x16 · HARD_GATES_PASS · Stories-safe ✓ / Reels band ✗
v5p-b-9x16 · HARD_GATES_PASS · Stories-safe ✓ / Reels band ✗

V5S — F**k Smelling Nice. Start Getting Laid.

Nice is forgettable. Pheromones bring her over. · winner-style still life · three sprays + roll-on · A: CLAIM 78% OFF → · B: SHOP THE $75 BUNDLE →

plate 4x5
v5s-a-4x5 · HARD_GATES_PASS · feed ✓ · 1:1 crop ✓
v5s-b-4x5 · HARD_GATES_PASS · feed ✓ · 1:1 crop ✓
plate 9x16
v5s-a-9x16 · HARD_GATES_PASS · Stories-safe ✓ / Reels band ✗
v5s-b-9x16 · HARD_GATES_PASS · Stories-safe ✓ / Reels band ✗