Wonder v40 — the shortlist, compiled

v40 — your shortlist, compiled

Everything you said you liked, in one place, with the three things you asked for added. 24 ads, 48 masters.

What I changed

The price is now on every single one.

“$14 first bottle · free shipping” at 36–40px on all 24. It was already there — but as 19–21px chrome nobody reads. It is now the second-largest thing in the frame after the headline, set as type on the photograph with no panel behind it. I also deleted the old fine-print copies so the price is said once, not twice.
Stars on every proof roundel. The navy “OVER 1,121 VERIFIED REVIEWS” variant had no stars — that was the one you were looking at. All three variants now carry them.
The product is on the before/afters. W07 and W08 had no bottle at all. The v20 transparent cutout now sits in the bottom corner opposite the proof roundel, below the headline — not held, just present, which is what you asked for.

A new gate for it: the price element is checked on every frame for presence, minimum 32px size, and overlap against every other element. 0 missing, 0 too small, 0 overlapping across all 48.

What I left out, and why

Dropped	Reason
v37r2 W05 — Reverse / Signs of Damaged Hair	Your call: “the oil is coming out of thin air and it looks stupid”. It is a plate fault, not a layout one, so it is out until that plate is reshot with the pour sourced from something.
v22r2, all ten	You landed on “I don't like any of those.” Also still carries the masthead-block question.
The 174 before/afters	“Forget all these.” The two that survive are W07 and W08, which are in this set.

Two things you should look at

The price line sits on the product on some of the v35 plates (group B). On B·W02, B·W09 and C·W04 it crosses a hand, an arm or a bottle reflection. The halo carries it and it reads, but it is not clean. Root cause is the one from earlier today: v35's plates run the product to the frame edge, so there is no clear bottom band. Reshooting those plates under the v38 band brief is the actual fix.

Two frames needed their headline moved to make room. Promoting the price meant lifting the bottom-slot roundels, which pushed one into “hair fast.” on W08's 4:5 — so that headline moved up 105px. And the price could not go under the headline on group A, because on W03 it landed on the dropper cap; it is seated in the bottom band on all three groups instead.

Gates — all 48 masters

Gate	A (8)	B (20)	C (20)
Text overflow	0	0	0
Solid blocks over size	0	0	0
Element collisions	0	0	0
Meta safe zone	10/10	20/20	20/20
Roundel over chrome	0	0	0
Price present / sized / clear	0 fail	0 fail	0 fail

Claims: groups B and C still carry the v35/v36 headlines — “REGROW HAIR FAST”, “Hair in Just 2 Weeks”, “GROW Healthier Hair Fast”. Those assert efficacy and timeframes Wonder has no evidence for, so this set is not cleared for placement. Group A is the same. Say the word and I will swap in the qualified hooks — the layout does not change, only the words.